When I started out as a music journalist, never did I think id be writing about two US popstars, both kids, both loaded and both teenage heartthrobs. I mean, fair enough, I can see why kids fancy vampire Robert Pattinson, or even Justin Timberlake, but Beiber and Archuleta, come on, have their voices even broken?
So, we’re looking to bring an end to the Justin Bieber Vs. David Archuleta nonsense, and once and for all let you, the fans decide who is best. We know making you pick is like asking a mum to pick her favourite child or asking me to choose between Sebastian Vettel and Giovanni Ribisi, but because we’re mean (and we can) we’ve decided to throw it open to the fans.
Okay, so this kinda means that is one boy has more fans than the other they’re bound to win… and whilst we reckon JB might have just a couple more teens on his side, our love for Mr Archuleta means we’re going to be ringing round all our mates and getting them to vote. No, we’re just joking, we wouldn’t want our ’scientific findings’ to be biased or anything.
So, here’s the boys current stats:
In the red corner….. David Archuleta
Birth name : David Archuleta
Born : December 28, 1990 (age 19)
Origin : Murray, Utah, U.S.
Genres : Pop
Occupations : Singer-songwriter, student, actor
Instruments : Vocals, piano, keyboards, guitar
Years active : 2003–present
Labels : Jive
David Archuleta is a strong contender having won the children’s division of the Utah Talent Competition at just 10 years old, before finishing as runner up of American Idol in 2008, receiving 44 percent of over 97 million votes.
His first single, Crush, was released just a few months later and whilst it only debuted at number two, it has since shifted just short of 2 million copies. He also Male Rising Star at the ALMA awards in 2009 as well as Breakout Artist, Love Song, and Best Tou at the Teen Choice Awards 2009, along with finding himself in the Forbes top ten for 2008.
And is one of my favourite songs on my ‘Car CD.’
In the blue corner…. Justin Bieber
Birth name : Justin Drew Bieber
Born : March 1, 1994 (age 16)
Origin : Stratford, Ontario, Canada
Genres : Pop, R&B
Occupation : Singer, songwriter
Instruments : Vocals, guitar, piano, percussion, trumpet
Years active : 2007–present
Labels : Island, RBMG
Associated acts : Usher, Ludacris, Sean Kingston
Justin Bieber might not be legally old enough to do much in the US, but that hasn’t stopped him kicking some musical ass ever since his YouTube performances were picked up by his now-manager Scooter Braun.
Annoyingly, he decided to release his debut album in two parts, and the leas single, One Time did exceptionally well, despite the fact I thought it was a girl singing until I saw the video in the gym about a month ago.
In all credit to him though, the first four singles from My World
The first part of his two-part[7] debut album My World was released on “One Time”, “One Less Lonely Girl”, “Love Me”, and “Favorite Girl”, were all Top 15 hits on the Canadian Hot 100 and Top 40 hits on the Billboard Hot 100 before the album was even released!
In less than a month of release, the album was certified Platinum in Canada, and in less than two months later, the album was certified Platinum in the United States, selling over a million copies. It was also certified Silver in the United Kingdom.
Unsurprisingly then, Bieber was named the hottest star of 2009 by J-14, newcomer of the year by MuchMusic, and listed by Celebuzz as one of the Top 10 YouTube stars of the decade – but has he won YOU over?
Vote below and let us know!
Ruth. xxx
DAVID ARCHULETA ftw!!
David Archuleta for the win !!
David has more passion in singing and has a pure angelic voice .
Plus!, He’s cute and adorable !
justin bieber all the way
thank u someone finally understand me girl u r rite justin bieber 4 d win
This is just Wrong. David should NEVER be COMPARED to Justin. David is worlds above Justin. Young girls like Justin cause of his cocky swagger, (by the way needed lessons for), they don’t care about whether the fact he can actually sing or not. B y the time this kid is 20 he will be soo ruined it’s not funny.
David’s voice is way beyond any “Diapered Darling” so theres no comparing them here.
girl u dont no whatcha talkin bout justin B is waYYYY better so no one should compare them
Ok.. I disagree with aj.. Seriously.. Tracy.. You’ve got really good points. People aren going to move on within a year with his stuff. Like the Jonas brothers but thank gosh they still have fans! And David.. Woww he can shine. People will at least remember him within the next 10 Years. That 10 year old?? No. Can you hear Davids soul when he sings. Beaver’s also Is a jerk. E brags about who he meets like everyday, tries to get famous every chance he gets (telling People he mer this famous person or what ever) davids just got this special thong about his voice. I don’t think of him as that runner up kid from american idol. Because I wasn’t his fan back then. I think of him as a professional singer and he’s working it! He’s succeeding. An making us proud. And personality wise, I don’t have to mention because David wins at that. And if you think beaver’s personality is better than David Archuletas? Then you’re dummer then a wheel of cheese seriously no offense though….. Don’t get tricked by his “charm” which I don’t see in him..
Sorry there were a lot of spelling mistakes because I’m typing on my iPod. I wanted to say he’s a jerk. And that people will forget about him soon.
DAVID ARCHULETA !
FOR REALZZZZ.
Voted for David Archuleta! Think he is great…
don’t see the reason for the competition though as there is enough room in the world for many artists!
Archie FTW!!!!
Oh, come on! How can you compare David with Bieber? I mean David’s voice vs. Bieber’s….please..
Everything you said about both of them describe Bieber perfectly, but not David.
Maybe David is 19 but you have to hear him talk…he’s so mature for his age…and for mine too..I’m 27 btw.
And no comment about his unbroken voice. Ok, maybe one…Open your ears!
DAVID ARCHULETA WIN!!
DAVID ARCHULETA WIN!!
DAVID ARCHULETA WIN!!
DAVID ARCHULETA WIN!!
DAVID ARCHULETA WIN!!
David Archuleta
oh come on….both are incomparable though i’m certain that the other boy will be in rehab
in no time.
he is so immature that he allowed himself to be corrupted by other people just to make money.
while the other is so mature for his age that he doesn’t allow people to manipulate him.
And for that i salute his parents.And of course he is so sincere and genuine like his talent.*winks*
Archuleta all the way. Can’t compare the two…one is trying really hard to be the next big pop star
while the other is building a long lasting career focusing on making relevant music.
All this artist bashing does is cause fan wars, I think we have enough wars going on this world ….don’t you?
Do you think bashing another artist will bring more fans to your favorite artist’s fanbase?
I wish them both well
David Archie!! ♥
well if you think that hotness and sexiness are what makes a ‘musician’, then you better go check your dictionary!
I was already a fan of David’s but seeing and hearing him sing in person was incredible! I am and will always will be a fan for life !David is the real deal there is no comparing the two.
vote for david! haha
I’m voting the Archuleta all the way. However, I do rather like Bieber. I’ve bought his videos and think he’s just adorable.
HELLO???? of course David Archuleta!!!!! his voice was totally unique!!! and i love his styles>>>>
for me its David no one else can compare to David>>>
A great singer, songwriter, artist, student!!!!!!
GO DAVIDARCHIE!!!!!!!! WE LOVE YOU SOOO MUCH!!!!!!
FOREVER!!!!!
there is simplly no comparison to the “one and only” David Archuleta. None! not from bieber or
any of season 9′s contestants. They just don’t have it. No matter what their managers, stylists or
coaches try to do to emulate the King of Idol. None can get near the Archuleta. Bieber is for one
not attractive. His face is too baby and his head is not in proportion with his body. Just sayin. He’s coached by people who want him to go the Black route. You know the lingo, the attitude. Basically
a wannabe Black artist. To me that’s phony. David Archuleta is himself. The real deal of talent and
gorgeous looks. Also a genuine sweetheart. Aaron Kelly, another wannabe Archuleta. He just dyed
his hair dark to appear more like the Archuleta. Why? because he’s sixteen? It aint gonna happen.
The kid does not own a voice like David’s. His looks are sort of bland and is probably why the idol
stylist instructed him to go darker and we know that it’s phony. Just like Lambert. He’s a real blonde.
They don’t own the dark hair like David. Archuleta. Kelly’s nose is similar to Ellen’s. He looks like
he’s related to Ellen. Just sayin. These new wannabe singers are trying too hard to emulate the Kind
of idol and the judges know it. Forget about’em all and on with David Archuleta! We need and miss
you David! So, So much. And so do the judges and is why they are trying so hard and unsuccessfully
to find one to fill your shoes. Honey, they can’t and won’t. You are meant to be the “King” of idol.
Not bieber, cook, kelly or anyone elst. WORD!
David Archuleta for sure.
I love him bcoz he is David hahaha
I do not care for contests like this … but still, I have to sound off and support my guy!
David Archuleta is sooooooo talented … he can sing anything!!!
Go David Archuleta . GO ! !
you’re my #1 idol !
hell yeah!! go team archie!! keep the votes going archangels. we’re leading. really leading.
)
let us not wait till that bieber kid goes down. lol
DAVID ARCHULETA of course!!!!!! yayayayaay
DAVID ARCHULETA <3
However, I agree that we shouldn't compare David and Justin.
They're two different people and they have their own unique personality.
For example, David has that soulful voice and he wants to be the role model to others.
Whereas, Justin has that very nice high voice, which is breaking…:/
No matter what, they're two very talented people.
David is older and more mature than Justin, but they both can sing.
If you're a true Bieber or Archuleta fan, you won't be dissing other celebs because you know that's what they wouldn't do.
So, no matter what the outcome, whether you're Team Bieber or Team Archuleta, they're both really talented.
DAVID ARCHULETA all the way ~~ !
No doubt David Archuleta is the best!!!~~
Of course, David Archuleta
David was not there that can match
He must be the winner!
<3 David Archuleta
DAVID ARCHULETA>>
DAVID ARCHULETA FOR THE WIN..But seriously, Bieber is good
archie♥
David Archuleta all the way!!!
David and Justin should not even be compared, cuz just look at the poll. Clearly David is the best.
quien es ese otro justin nadie lo conoseovio voto por mi amor David archuleta ♥ lo amooooo
archie el mejorr
the only comparison bet David and Justin is that they both started at the thender age of sixteen, other than that DAVID is beyond compare,he is the best.
are you kidding ?! Team Archuleta of coursee
No one and I mean that, no one has ever touched me the way David Archuleta has with his voice and his sweet humble personality. In the years ahead, I will still be listening to David Archuleta..he is not just another new fad! Not sure I can say that about the other pop star, don’t listen to him now so I don’t know what the futuer has i nstore for him..Nothing against him, but he is just another teen idol to me where as David is a real musician.
ABSOLUTELY….
DAVID ARCHULETA..
YOU ARE MY NUMBER ONE IDOL..!!!!
David Archuleta has a wonderful voice and sings with so much emotion. He is amazing!! Justin just doesn’t do it for me!!
David has a fantastic voice, is good looking, humble and isn’t stuck on himself like Justin Beiber is!! David Archuleta is awesome!!
NO COMPARISON.
David Archuleta FTW!!!!
Plus Bieber is cocky, sounds like a girl, and by the time he’s David’s age, will probably be runined.
DAVID ARCHULETA ROCKS!!
Of couse my David Archuleta is the Winner! ‘Cause, his voice is so great,so pure! And he’s so cute and better than Justin. .All the way. . Go Archie Go! I love u!!
Totally David! He’s just so adorable.
Anyway I vote to David.
It’s totally no chance for Justin Bieber to win.
And it’s NO COMPARISON.
David Archuleta is amazing!!
David Archuleta is a good guy
I love him…
yeah !! evrybody knows !!
DAVID ARCHULETA !!
what a big difrenc guys..
good job..
I love David Archuleta!!
David Archuleta gets my vote because he has a fantastic voice, is the cutest & sweetest guy ever!! Love him!!
i wish he will b the winner forever..
real winner of course..