by Jenny S. on Sun Nov 26, 2006 7:25 pm
May I make a second, and final, contribution to this strand :
Firstly, I apologise if I seemed to belittle Janet007's experience. If those spankings were painful and humiliating then I sympathise. I should have made it clearer that my use of Keith's word "lucky" was ironic in large measure.
As for my own experience, perhaps I came off lighter than Janet. The punishment was administered by a woman (a very important distiction) and I did not have the humiliation of being put over someone's knee. Instead I was politely invited to bend over a chair. Afterwards she gave me a hanky to dry my eyes (I'm ashamed to say I wept a little) and then told I could sit quietly in the Library until I felt able to go back into class.
I, too, am against corporal punishment and have never used it on my two daughters (now 26 & 24). Afterall, I know how much it hurts - the cane at least. But back then the shame and disgrace of being expelled would have been worse, for me at any rate, and a sore bottom seemed the better option. It made a full recovery and now the whole thing is a vivid if unpleasant memory !