Moderator: Silent One
. wrote:its a saxo vts.
rehan wrote:buy a fat turbo charger and your be on your way
Misanthrope wrote:rehan wrote:buy a fat turbo charger and your be on your way
Yes, on your way to knock/Detonation heaven because your compression ratio is too high and your ignition map is too advanced for the octane/boost from the Turbocharger. I.e your engine becomes scrap!
Try to speak with knowledge/experience or else don't!
. wrote:Misanthrope wrote:rehan wrote:buy a fat turbo charger and your be on your way
Yes, on your way to knock/Detonation heaven because your compression ratio is too high and your ignition map is too advanced for the octane/boost from the Turbocharger. I.e your engine becomes scrap!
Try to speak with knowledge/experience or else don't!
Hey, that's a bit harsh. Rehan's advice was incomplete but not necessarily wrong. There are a lot of performance shops that will do the conversion, including the re-mapping and head work.
Although, if you have a Japanese car its often better value to buy a grey import replacement engine from Japan complete with turbo, intercooler and engine management computer.
You'bve obviously missed the point also- you must lower the compression ratio, i.e change the pistons. So it's not a case of just bolting on a Turbo.
. wrote:You'bve obviously missed the point also- you must lower the compression ratio, i.e change the pistons. So it's not a case of just bolting on a Turbo.
I never said it was simple, nor did I preclude changing the pistons as one mod that might be needed. I noted Rehan’s statement was not wrong but incomplete and that your comment was harsh.
For most 4 cylinder modern engines, turbo charging is of course no simple matter. This is not true for all engines and there are some over-engineered power plants with lower compression usually of 6 cylinder configuration that will handle a turbo with minimal change providing they are not wildly blow.
Our preferred method of turbo charging has been, as I noted earlier, to replace the entire power plant with a gray import. Engine, turbo, computer and gearbox takes around 2 days to fit where the manufacturer has used the same vehicle for their naturally aspirate model. The whole exercise lands up costing about the same as rebuilding your old engine. Of course, it depends on the laws in your country as to whether you’re supposed to do this.
You're obviously from North America where perhaps your "6 cylinder engines" have low compression ratios as standard. s52 BMW M3 units are 11.3:1, Porsche 993 3.8 litre 6 cylinder- 11.3:1, even the Jaguar AJV6 runs aclose to 11:1. I know a back street garage who boosts Porsche 968s and claims that just boosting it is enough, no piston change is required. This is ridiculous.
What back street places garages do, varies, most of them don't know what they're doing anyway.
I've seen engines mapped wildly away from MBT such that the exhaust valves are about to fall off , never mind the catalyst melting.
Simplifying engine performance mods is foolish, but often done by ignorant folk. OEMs put alot of effort into engine development only to have some "know-it-all" "do better".
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests