mogadishu wrote:Of course I'm not(that's an ad hominem attack btw)
They don't specify any action, any fact, so it's impossible to be able to say whether their facts are right or wrong. A basic truth wihcih seems to have eluded you.
and of course "Christianity in Germany bears a greater responsibility before God than the National Socialists, the SS, and the Gestapo." is a value judgment. My point was, as you (fallaciously) implied the scholars you quoted were above reproach in virtue of being scholars (or Jewish) or whatever, I quoted a (world renowned) scholar to demonstarte that scholarly opinion on this subject was not uniform.
Where do I call Sharett a liar?
Again, I did not only quote scholars. I quoted leaders who referred to events and actions of which they had contemporaneous knowledge.
The quote you posted from the so-called "world renowned" scholar -- not in history obviously -- is a naked value judgment with zero factual support.
And where did you call Sharret a liar?
"The state of Israel must invent dangers"
"That ... doesn't make him a liar"
hmmm
