Reader's Comments

Back to: Best & Worst Of Gerard Butler

by Dorothy (Dotty) McMillan 8 November 2011

I agree with most of these choices for best and worst. However, there is one with which I heartily disagree. P.S. I Love You is a lovely movie, and it wasn't required that it fit the book perfectly. I've followed Gerry since he did "Her Majesty, Mrs Brown". but none of my friends knew who he was for a long time. Then, I treated a number of those friends to seeing "P.S. I Love you", which they absolutely loved it! And It made them all great fans. Most all of them cried at the end. The second thing is that you missed the very worst of Gerry's Movies. And that is GAMER. A waste of Gerry's talents. A waste of time spent trying to watch it. It should have been a brilliant,updated version of Tron. It was so dreadful it was pathetic. Dorothy (Dotty) who now lives in Oz