The next morning, Ned barely wakes up with the car filled with carbon monoxide fumes. He gets Emerson out, who is relieved to be alive, but they spot a new snowman in the Newsome’ yard.
Olive goes to visit the aunts bringing them the pie she has baked. She is unaware that she has actually overdosed it with the herbal mood-enhancer, because she thought it was a weak-tasting vanilla. Olive reacts suddenly when Lily says she’s seen Charlotte’s ‘ghost’, but skips over the matter. Lily finishes off the entire pie and starts hallucinating about the decorations coming to life. She points out there’s no vanilla in the pie, making Olive wonder exactly what the secret ingredient was.
Meanwhile, Chuck makes pies and wonders what Oscar might discover. He arrives and gives her back her hair as a gesture of trust, and to give her the chance to tell him her secret. She realises there’s only one person she wants to talk to about her secret, and that’s Ned.
Emerson and Ned watch the coroners remove Kevin’s body from Emma’s front yard, while Emerson realises that Emma was peeling potatoes, like the one they found in their exhaust pipe. They prepare to touch Kevin’s body and discover the truth, but the coroners drops it and it shatters. Ned is mortified by the situation and refuses to bring it back to life. Instead, they go inside the house to find that Abner has been rejected yet again for a heart transplant. Emma mentions that McLean had asked for the name of the adjuster who refuses Abner’s most recent transplant request. It was Steve Kaiser. Ned and Emerson realise McLean is the killer and head for Uber-Life. McLean pulls into the parking lot where Kaiser is just getting into his car.
Ned and Emerson close in on McLean while Ned tries to find out more about Emerson’s daughter. McLean takes a swing at Kaiser and just misses, then pins him down to deliver the final blow. Ned and Emerson confront her but she pulls a gun and says her job is to grant wishes. It turns out that McLean was depressed that Abner had no wishes for her to grant, until he said he wanted the insurance adjusters who rejected him to drop dead. As this goes on, they are all unaware that Bobo the bonobo is playing with the gear stick in McLean's van and runs her over. She is killed, but her heart is intact, so Abner finally receives his transplant.
Ned goes to the cemetery to find Chuck at her father’s grave. She admits she feels better and asks Ned to bring her father back to life. Ned refuses, not wanting to be responsible for killing him again, even though Chuck begs him. Back at the aunt’s house, Lily hallucinates about floating mermaids and talks about how she secretly made snow angels in the back yard for the young Charlotte. Lily then reveals to Olive that she is actually Charlotte’s mother.