Richard Attenborough

Richard Attenborough

Lord Richard Attenborough has sleighed Billy Bob Thornton to be named the Best Santa Claus on the big screen. 

To mark Christmas 2010 LOVEFiLM asked over 1000 of its members to vote for the Best Movie Santa, with Attenborough’s portrayal as kind-hearted Kris Kringle in 1994 Christmas favourite, Miracle on 34th Street earning him top spot on the nation’s nice list with nearly a third of the votes (26 per cent).

A surprising second on the poll with 14 per cent was Billy Bob Thornton’s turn as a drunken thieving conman who dresses as Santa to rob department stores in Bad Santa.

The perfect catharsis to generic Christmas film fare, this unlikely festive tale gave the bad boy actor an advantage over other classic Clauses on the list…

Ho-ho-ho-ing into third place with ten per cent is Tim Allen as divorcee Scott Calvin in The Santa Clause; he is disgusted to learn his ex and her husband have told his son that Santa isn’t real.

His son’s belief is firmly restored when Tim Allen unexpectedly gets a new job as the big man himself.

Sugar and spice and all things nice, David Huddlestone left the nation’s hearts aglow as Father Christmas in 1985’s classic Santa Claus: The Movie.

Supported by an all star cast including Dudley Moore and John Lithgow, the film answered every child’s questions from how reindeer’s fly to how Santa ascends the chimney securing Huddlestone fourth place in the poll (nine per cent).

Miracle on 34th Street appears again in the top ten with nine per cent of the votes for Edmund Gwenn’s original 1947 performance as Kris Kringle.

The movie won Academy Awards for Best Actor (Edmund Gwenn), Best Writing, Original Story and Best Writing, Screenplay – undoubtedly one of the best festive flicks of all time.

Others making the top ten Best Santa Clauses include Father Christmases from The Nightmare Before Christmas, The Grinch, The Polar Express, and Elf.

The Best Film Santa Clauses were as follows:

1. Richard Attenborough in Miracle on 34th Street (1994) – 26%
2. Billy Bob Thornton in Bad Santa – 14%
3. Tim Allen in The Santa Clause – 10%
4. David Huddlestone in Santa Claus: The Movie (1985) – 9%
5. Edmund Gwenn in Miracle on 34th Street (1947) –9%
6. Jack Skellington  in The Nightmare Before Christmas – 8%
7. Jim Carey in The Grinch – 6%
8. Tom Hanks in  The Polar Express (2003) – 4%
9. Ed Asner in Elf – 3 %
10. Mel Smith in Raymond Brigg’s Father Christmas – 2%

(Other – 9%)